"Evaluation is not only a way to measure progress but also a tool to drive it."

Job evaluation has become a vital aspect of any job in modern times. The cognitive level, physical labor, and working conditions determine the value of a job.

Job evaluation came into the picture to maintain fair pay, but it has brought more than that by increasing efficiency, improving the recruitment process, and offering a strong foundation for the companies to operate.

According to reports, about [65% of the US population are happy with their jobs, while 49% are extremely satisfied with their work]. Job evaluation performed by the companies helps in understanding the job's worth and allocating resources for it, which increases employee satisfaction and performance.

As an HR, a significant part of your job responsibility includes evaluating job performance to determine the salary for different job roles. By using job evaluation methods, you can find equitable compensation for every job role.

Read on to learn more about job evaluation, its methods, steps involved, along with the following FAQs:

What is Job Evaluation?

Job evaluation is a process that is used to gauge the relative importance of various positions within any organization. In order to assess each job's worth compared to other jobs, it is necessary to compare its duties, qualifications, and other characteristics.

The next obvious question you must be wondering is, what is the main objective of job evaluation?

Through comparison and survey, job evaluation helps eliminate inequalities as the organizations can utilize the gathered data to decide on job design, resource allocation, and build fair and equitable pay ranges, which is its major objective.

International Labour Office (ILO) gives job evaluation definition as Job evaluation is an attempt to determine and compare the demands which the normal performance of a particular job makes on normal workers, without taking into account the individual abilities or performance of the workers concerned.

Job performance evaluation can also help to assess the skills and expertise of certain employees to identify their potential for advancement or career development.

Job Evaluation vs. Performance Appraisal

Job evaluation and performance appraisal are two related but distinct HR practices. As an HR, you will be responsible for both job evaluation and performance appraisal.

While job evaluation determines the relative worth of different jobs within an organization, performance appraisal assesses the individual performance of employees in their current roles.

Employees' skills, knowledge, and talents, as well as their overall job performance and organizational contributions, are all evaluated as part of the performance appraisal process.

Performance appraisal is often used to identify areas where employees may need training or support and can also be used to make decisions about promotions, salary increases, and other career development opportunities.

Both practices ensure that employees are fairly compensated and supported in their careers.

Also Read: What is employee attrition rate and why is it important?

What Are the Different Job Evaluation Methods?

There are several methods that organizations can use to evaluate the relative worth of different jobs. Given below are some of the most common methods:

Ranking Method of Job Evaluation

In this method, jobs are ranked from lowest to highest in terms of their importance to the organization. It can be done using various job evaluation criteria, such as the skills and experience required for the job, the level of responsibility, and the level of supervision required.

The positions with the highest scores are listed first, while those with the lowest ones are listed last.

Classification Method of Job Evaluation

This method groups jobs into classes or grades based on their similarities and differences. For example, all clerical jobs can be classified as 'office support.'

Each class or grade is assigned a pay range, and jobs are then assigned to the right class or grade based on their level of responsibility, skills required, and other factors.

Point Method of Job Evaluation

In the point method of job evaluation, jobs are evaluated based on a set of factors or 'points' that apply to the job's value.

These factors can be the level of education or training required, the degree of responsibility, and the job's physical demands. Each factor is assigned a certain number of points, and the total points for each role are used to determine its value in relation to other jobs.

The point method of job evaluation is the most popular approach for assessing a job. It can be used for various purposes and is relatively easy to use and comprehend.

Factor Comparison Method of Job Evaluation

In the factor comparison method, jobs are evaluated based on a set of factors relevant to the job's value. These factors include the level of education or training required, the level of responsibility, and the job's physical demands.

Each factor is assigned a weight to reflect its relative importance. The weights are used to compare the jobs and determine their relative worth.

A factor comparison method is a good option for larger organizations as they can bear the expenses involved in the process.

The most appropriate method of job evaluation will depend on the specific needs and goals of the organization. It is important for organizations to carefully consider their options and choose a method that is fair, objective, and consistent with their overall HR strategy.

What Are the Steps in Job Evaluation?

The specific steps involved in a job evaluation process will vary depending on the method used and the specific goals for job evaluation. Given below are some common steps that you can use as an HR for job evaluation:

1. Identify the Jobs and Determine the Scope

The first step in job evaluation is to find the jobs that must be evaluated. It might apply to every position throughout the company, or to a specific division or functional area.
Once you have identified the job, you need to determine its scope by answering questions like; if it is a new evaluation or revaluation, whether you will adjust the budgets, and how much pay will be fixed for each job.


2. Create a Job Evaluation Committee

As an HR, you will play an active role in deciding who will participate in the job evaluation process.

To ensure that the evaluation process is objective and fair, the evaluation committee can be of great help. This committee should include representatives from different departments or functional areas and HR personnel.

3. Choose a Job Evaluation Method

The next step in the job evaluation process is to choose a job evaluation method that best suits your company. You can choose any of the above-discussed job evaluation methods to make the process easy.

You should consider common factors like the level of education or training required, the level of responsibility, and the job's physical demands if you choose the hay method or point method.

These factors will become the units to standardize your job evaluation system.

4. Collect Information for Job Evaluation

Once the factors used in the evaluation have been identified and you have selected a job evaluation method, the next step is to collect and analyze the relevant data.

It includes conducting job analyses to gather information about the responsibilities and requirements of each job, as well as surveying employees to gather their perceptions of the job's value.

Also Read: What is HR Analytics and why is it important in 2023?

5. Assign Values to the Jobs

The next step in the evaluation process is assigning values based on collected and analyzed data. It could be classifying the jobs into grades or classes, ranking them from lowest to highest, or giving them a particular number of points based on the job evaluation criteria.

Hiration pro tip:
Ensure to seek insights from the job evaluation committee and research well at every step to avoid chances of error in the job evaluation process.

6. Communicate the Result

The last step in the job evaluation process is communicating any change in the reward structure with the employees to stay fair. If the employees have suggestions, implement them in the job evaluation process and be open to reevaluation.

Keep in mind that the pay structure is at the core of any job evaluation. You can use it to improve your team's skillset and work experience and motivate them to enhance their development.

Also Read: What are employee benefits and why should they be offered?

What Are the Benefits of Job Evaluation?

Job evaluation can provide several advantages for organizations. Given below are some common benefits of job evaluation:

  • It helps organizations decide fair and equitable pay scales, leading to job satisfaction for employees and increased productivity.
  • It can help evaluate the important factors which lead to better job design and allocation of resources.
  • It helps in supporting the career development of employees by giving an idea about the skills and knowledge required for different jobs.
  • It enhances the overall effectiveness of organizations by making them practice fair and just methods which align with their overall goals.
  • By maintaining a compensation structure based on the relative worth of jobs, job evaluation reduces the likelihood of disputes between the labor union and management.

Also Read: Why should your company be an equal opportunity employer?

Limitations of Job Evaluation

While job evaluation can provide many benefits for organizations, there are also some limitations. Given below are some major disadvantages of job evaluation:

  • Conducting job evaluation can be time-consuming and expensive for organizations with limited resources as it includes gathering data for many jobs.
  • Job evaluation can become prone to biases if not designed and implemented carefully. The evaluation factors need to be objective, and the data collected should be accurate to avoid errors.
  • It can lead to employee dissatisfaction if the results are not adequately valued, affecting the organization's productivity.

Key Takeaways

  • Job evaluation is defined as the process of finding the importance of different jobs in an organization and establishing a hierarchy.
  • A job evaluation process should be systematic, objective, and fair to ensure that the relative worth of different jobs is accurately determined.
  • A job evaluation assesses the worth of a job, while a performance appraisal is used to evaluate the individual performance of the employees.
  • Ranking, classification, point, or factor comparison methods are the four most popular job evaluation methods.
  • The steps to perform job evaluation includes, identifying the job and determining the scope, creating a job evaluation committee, choosing a job evaluation method, collecting information, and assigning values to the jobs.
  • There are several benefits of job evaluation, including increased productivity and employee satisfaction, better allocation of resources, and career development of employees.
  • The major drawback of performing job evaluation is its ability to become prey to human biases and subjectivity.

Visit Hiration's Career Activator Platform with 24x7 chat support if you're looking for career guidance.

Build your resume in 10 minutes
Use the power of AI & HR approved resume examples and templates to build professional, interview ready resumes
Create My Resume
out of 5 on